Friday, January 28, 2022

"I'm a burnt-out barista, and I don't know if I'll return to my minimum wage job"/ "Small businesses face 'bloodbath' in Ontario clampdown: Restaurateur"


Oct. 21, 2021 "I'm a burnt-out barista, and I don't know if I'll return to my minimum wage job": Today I found this article by Chloe Peel on CBC news.  This was really good and tells about her experience working and going to school during the pandemic:


 This First Person column is the experience of Chloe Peel, a student and barista in Montreal who is currently on leave for burnout. For more information about CBC's First Person stories, please see the FAQ.

"We're hiring!" signs adorn the doors and windows of seemingly every business in Montreal, and yet nobody seems to be applying. Everyone is wondering where the workers have gone, and yet nobody is checking in on those workers — often students and young people — who still occupy these service jobs.

The reality is that we're burned out. I speak from experience as I am a 21 year old currently on medical leave from my job as a barista due to the enormous stress of this seemingly easy job.

Even before the pandemic, young people were speaking out about the low minimum wage in Quebec, about employers not being flexible enough with our work schedules to accommodate school and internships, about clientele being increasingly rude and demanding much more. Since then, our list of frustrations has gotten exponentially longer. 

We worked in person from day one of the pandemic, stocking grocery store and pharmacy shelves and preparing quick meals for essential workers (the reason fast food restaurants stayed open). Not only have we been the public's only consistent in-person interactions over the past nearly two years, but we also became enforcers of public health regulations. From mask mandates starting in July 2020 to the still-new vaccine passport, we're the ones who have to enforce these rules. We're the face of changes that so many people don't understand, and are often reluctant to comply with.

This leads to a lot of abuse. I've had people yell and swear at me. A fellow barista had a drink thrown at them.

With the mounting pressure on us at work, on top of also having to adapt to our new lives of Zoom university and our social and dating lives coming to a complete halt — which left us isolated in our tiny student apartments — many of us tried to speak up. 

The general response: if you don't like your work conditions, find another job. So, facing job insecurity and public apathy, we did as we were told and found other sources of income.

At my cafĂ©, less than half of the staff from this time last year is still around. Many quit out of frustration; others, like me, were advised by medical and mental health specialists to take some time off. This crisis has a domino effect. 

Once a handful of people quit, we become short staffed and clients get longer wait times, which in turn leads to more complaints from frustrated clients that we try to manage — only further discouraging the brave souls who have been sticking it out.

And why would anyone want to apply for a job in an environment where the current staff are barely hanging on? Especially for our strikingly low minimum wage.

But at the same time, quitting isn't an option for everyone — meaning the risk of burnout for some is even higher. Young people typically work service jobs to pay for school or to build up experience in their field. For this system to work, these "student jobs" can't be our entire lives.

Applying for new jobs is time and energy consuming, and interviews and training tend to have much less scheduling flexibility than the shifts we would work once we're hired. Many of us simply can't afford that instability.

To all those asking what happened to service workers? We either escaped the industry or crumbled under the pressure, after being constantly reminded that nobody really cares about "unskilled labour." As for what to do now, I suggest taking time to listen to those who are still around. Most of us simply want to be treated, and paid, fairly. We deserve better, so either provide better working conditions and wages or accept that we're moving on.

Even after the Canada Recovery Benefit ends, these problems aren't going anywhere.

Chloe Peel is a young woman with a penchant for writing who hopes to use her voice to advocate for the issues that affect young working-class adults.

I'm a burnt-out barista, and I don't know if I'll return to my minimum wage job | CBC News

There are 23 comments:

  • 1 day ago
The comments here clearly illustrate the negative perception of those making minimum wage: if you make minimum wage, you are less than, and deserve the poverty, the abuse, and lack of economic support. The people on here saying go work elsewhere or suck it up are the problem. If you've done better in your life or worked harder means you were fortunate enough to be able to do so, and just because someone else wasn't able to do the same doesn't make you better or them worse. You need people in these jobs, they are providing all of us with valuable service, treat them with the same professionalism you would your peers, they are people, same as you. It's the least anyone deserves. « less

     
    • 1 day ago
    The problem isn't minimum wage it's taxation. Why are min wage employees paying punitive taxes while the government turns around and gives that money to people who don't work. The minimum personal exemption should be a full time min wage income. We should also allow more deductions for workers, like transportation some costs. Make work attractive, and limit the freebies to the able bodied.
       
      • 1 day ago
      I can agree with better working conditions part. The service industry can be a nasty business, but at the same time...... some money is better than no money.
         
        • 1 day ago
        With spiraling inflation and soaring prices, I expect many of these service jobs will disappear as some of these businesses fold due to the fact many depend upon the dwindling disposable income of others to survive.
           
          • 1 day ago
          The owners of bars and restaurants not only get money for the people they employ, they also collect additional support from the province and feds. But they can't see their way to pay anything more than the bare minimum, which costs them about $4 an hour and the feds pay the rest. The employees are not treated very well and things like, "can you work a couple hours extra" or worse " it's a little slow today, so you can go home". And never complain, even if the customer threatens you. Having to ... » more
             
            • 1 day ago
            Reply to @w a powers: maybe because of the virus rules and regulations resulting in much higher costs and the lackn of customers they are allowed they are just barely breaking even, so the owners work for nothing how would you consider that being fair.
               
              • 1 day ago
              Reply to @w a powers:
              I thought in Saskatchewan, we had a minimum call out of 3 hours, regardless whether or not it is busy enough. Used to be that way and I don't think it has changed.
                 
                • 1 day ago
                Reply to @w a powers: everything is a cycle, and there isnt such thing as "a free lunch". Money like all resources, like everything else is life, is finite. So u getting more means someone else is getting less. It is nice to talk about a "living wage" for low level or unskilled labour, but who is paying for it? The customers. That drive up the cost for customers, so they have to get additional $$ somewhere, so they demand higher wages from their companies, round and round it goes. So the ... » more
                   
                  • 1 day ago
                  One thing the pandemic made explicit is the value of our service workers --cashiers at various stores, delivery folks. They deserve more than minimum wage! As well, nurses should not be getting so much less than a police constable etc. Indeed, we should question the inequities in our society anew.

                  https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/ontario-gig-workers-uber-lyft-skip-employees-1.6216443
                     
                    • 1 day ago
                    Reply to @Don Kam: Just because you see it as an inequity doesn't make it true. Nobody deserves anything, period.
                       
                      • 1 day ago
                      Reply to @Don Kam: that's great, but who is paying for it? It is always nice to say, pay everyone more, but no one asks who is paying for it.
                         
                        • 1 day ago
                        The most telling means of judging the character of a person is by how they treat service personnel.
                        No one should be expected to be treated with rudeness and disrespect regardless of the status of their job.
                        If you have a friend who is nice to you but treats servers like trash, just remember, that's how they would be treating you if your roles were reversed.
                           
                          • 1 day ago
                          Reply to @Rick Bailey:
                          But my question to you is where did they learn this or who taught them this Behavior
                             
                            • 1 day ago
                            The wages will have to increase substantially if you want workers, businesses that depend on slave wages will disappear.
                               
                              • 2 days ago
                              Nothing but respect for those who kept the shelves stock, gas stations operating, managed drive through windows and many others while their buds bought bit coin with their new found wealth.

                              Say thanks to them and leave a tip, or more. They deserve it.
                                 
                                • 2 days ago
                                whoever said working with the public is easy? Maybe it's fun making coffee and that however the hard part of being a barista is always representing the employer and serving impatient patrons.
                                   
                                  • 2 days ago
                                  It would seem we have become a work adverse society and the real question should be why? How about government deficit funding to deliver growing expectations is, in our case, a serious but growing systemic problem?! It means we are expecting more from government than we are delivering in the form of a collective workforce productivity to support it? And even worse, is it moving up the food chain?

                                  How about what we are observing is the need for growing low skill jobs as part of our changing real economy? The problem, their decupling from their ability to support a basic standard of living? They are part of our social economic echo system, as are the needs for people to fill them! STOP the notion these people need to get better educated or need a change in attitude and self motivation! That is insulting and little else!

                                  The solution is not found in GDP growth to rationalize greater funded public debt as a solution by government! Even less, public subsidy of growing numbers thinking they do not need to work because society can afford it, in our current context?

                                  We need a full workforce that is diversified and productive to meet all our needs to deliver economic Alpha?

                                  Knowing the system can also be a full time job, but is it productive for society, if that is a growth area for able body workers? « less
                                     
                                    • 2 days ago
                                    Reply to @Michael Boucher:
                                    you seem to be portraying barista as no-skilled employment. Sure the physical skills are not extremely difficult, however not many people have the inter-personal skills necessary to serve the public in such an environment without getting burned out
                                       
                                      • 1 day ago
                                      Reply to @Michael Boucher: The thing is though that that minimum wages have been left in the dust by rising prices. I know it varies by province , but where I live in Manitoba it's under $12 per hour . I think Ontario is around $15 but of course their cost of living is higher . These are poverty wages , so if people can find another path , then good on them .
                                         
                                        • 2 days ago
                                        And the sheer lack of empathy or compassion shown here is stunning to me. Not everyone lives your life and has had your opportunities. Stop judging other's situations from your exalted place
                                           
                                          • 2 days ago
                                          The minimum wage was introduced in Ontario in 1918 with the idea that a person, working forty hours in one of those jobs, would be able to afford rent, food and necessities. It was an incredibly wise and compassionate social program that elevated Canada's standing in the world greatly. Since then, it has become a joke. I work multiple minimum wage service industry jobs (as no one will hire you full time and have to pay you vacation and or benefits). In a fifty five hour work week I can pay my ... » more
                                             
                                            • 2 days ago
                                            Working with the public many times is soul destroying sometimes.
                                               
                                              • 2 days ago
                                              For this woman and many in her situation, the pandemic has provided them with an opportunity to rethink their future. Now these people can take stock of their skills and either get some additional education or training to be able to find a job that will provide them with opportunity for the rest of their lives.
                                              Jan. 4, 2022 "Small businesses face 'bloodbath' in Ontario clampdown: Restaurateur": Today I found this article by David George-Cosh on Bloomberg news:

                                              Ontario's new rules aimed at curbing the spread of the Omicron COVID-19 variant may lead to a "bloodbath" for small businesses already struggling to stay afloat, according to one restaurant owner. 

                                              Mohamad Fakih, founder and chief executive officer of Paramount Fine Foods, an Ontario-based chain of Middle Eastern restaurants, said in an interview Tuesday he wants the Ontario and federal governments to provide additional assistance to affected businesses, notably those in the restaurant sector, to avoid widespread closures. 

                                              "It's very, very difficult for people to continue getting these restrictions, one after the other; businesses can not stay open," Fakih said. "We saw a lot of restaurants that were lost in our community because they couldn't stay open during COVID." 

                                              Ontario Premier Doug Ford announced the new restrictions Monday following what he described as a "tsunami" of new COVID-19 cases in the province over the past several weeks and as hospitals put off non-urgent surgeries as staff prioritize treating people suffering from the virus. Those new restrictions, which take effect Wednesday, include a ban on indoor dining as well as ordering gyms, theatres, concert venues, and many other indoor businesses to temporarily shut down. The measures will be in place until at least Jan. 26, the government said.  

                                              Fakih said that while he agrees with the latest restrictions aimed at stopping the spread of the Omicron variant, those new rules are likely to throw a wrench in plans for many small business owners who have taken on significant debt to keep their doors open during the pandemic. A recent study by the Canadian Federation of Independent Business (CFIB) found that small businesses have added an average of $190,000 in debt to stay in business despite various provincial lockdowns. 

                                              "By the time you create a repayment plan on your debts and the pattern of bringing some profit, they change the restrictions again and you start all over to replan your financial bottom line," Fakih said. 

                                              Ontario said it is providing some deferrals on property taxes and an energy rebate to small businesses during the current lockdown period, but the CFIB said in a release on Monday that those supports are not nearly enough to help organizations impacted by the newly-announced restrictions. 

                                              Paramount operates more than 70 locations around the world, the majority of which are located in Ontario. Fakih was named to the Order of Canada last month for his philanthropic work aiding new immigrants to Canada. 

                                              Over the years, Fakih expanded his business by employing many of those immigrants to work at Paramount, offering new Canadians a steady job and an opportunity to contribute to the country's economy. However, the latest lockdowns bring in labour uncertainty that could make it harder for restaurants to re-hire any lost staff, he added. 

                                              "We have lost a lot of employees who do not want to be in the restaurant business anymore," he said. "You hire them, then you let them go, then you hire them, then you let them go and that's not sustainable for anyone to do the career."​

                                              Small businesses face 'bloodbath' in Ontario clampdown: Restaurateur - BNN Bloomberg

                                              No comments: