Friday, July 19, 2024

"Sesame Street gets it right with Julia" (autistic character)/ "TV's attempts at autistic characters get mixed reviews"

Apr. 17, 2017 "Sesame Street gets it right with Julia": Today I found this article by Mari- Jane Williams in the Edmonton Journal:


Julia, the new Muppet who debuts today on Sesame Street, has a bright red mop of hair, a sunny yellow face and big green eyes. She is adorable and we are smitten by her laugh, her love of singing and her inventive game of Boing-Boing tag.

She also has autism, and the long-running show’s portrayal of the condition that affects 1 in 68 kids is sensitive and nuanced, a hint at the years of research that went into carefully crafting this lovely 4-year-old friend for Elmo, Abby Cadabby and the rest of the crew.

A child watching might not notice the subtleties, such as 

how the other characters don’t ask Julia a lot of open-ended questions, 

but rather offer or choices or say things to elicit a reaction. 

Or that Julia sometimes repeats a question before answering. 

But as a parent of a child with autism, that quiet distinction stuck with me. 

It’s exactly what I’ve found works best in communicating with my son.

It’s no surprise that Sesame Workshop, which manages the show, gets so much right with Julia, given how long the show worked on her — they began looking into creating a character for the Sesame Street and Autism: See amazing in all children site and books about 5 years ago, according to Sherrie Westin, executive vice president for Global Impact and Philanthropy at Sesame Workshop. 

They consulted at least 14 organizations

including people with autism 

and those who work with them 

or have family members who are autistic

because they wanted to get as much input as possible.

“There are a lot of different opinions in the autism community and they’re not all aligned,” Westin said. “But this was not about a cause or a cure or any of the divisive issues. Everyone was willing to come together around the goals and objectives because it was about destigmatizing autism, and helping children feel like they’re not alone.”

And as cool as it is for children with autism to see themselves reflected in a Muppet, Julia has a lot to offer typically developing kids as well. When I told my kids (both of whom aged out of Sesame Street many years ago) about the new character, they were excited. 

But it was my daughter who had the strongest reaction. Essentially, she said, maybe now kids will finally get it, and how great would that be?

That was part of the goal, Westin said.

“We came away feeling like there were two objectives here,” Westin said. 

“One was to create a resource for families with autism, to make their day easier. 

The other was to destigmatize autism and address the community at large. 

We wanted to create greater understanding and awareness of what autism looks like — 

more understanding, 

more empathy 

and, ultimately, more inclusion.” 

With that in mind, here are four things typical kids (and adults) can learn from watching Julia.


How to interpret flapping and sensory issues. 

The short answer: Matter-of-factly. Julia’s Muppet friends acknowledge that she flaps her arms when she’s excited, that she prefers painting with a brush to using her fingers, and that she is particularly sensitive to loud noises such as sirens. 

Even though these gestures and sensitivities make Julia a bit different from her pals, they don’t set her apart in any meaningful way.

The characters explain to Big Bird that while a siren might not seem loud to him, it can be a painful sound for someone with heightened sensitivity to noises. They incorporate Julia’s bouncing into a game of tag, making it more fun for everyone. 

By treating these things as simply another part of who Julia is (and emphasizing that we’re all different in our own way), the Muppets teach kids to take it in stride.



Autistic kids like (or dislike) a lot of the same things you do. Tag? Check. “Twinkle, Twinkle Little Star”? Check. Stuffed animals? That too. 

Elmo and friends find that Julia shares their interests, even if she sees the world through a different lens

The characterization helps kids find common ground with people with autism, 

while respectfully teaching about differences and how to honor them.



People with autism don’t need to be fixed. Instead of trying to make Julia more like a typical person, or setting out to “fix” her, the Muppets meet her where she is and engage with her through play, the same way they would engage with any of their friends. 

There’s nothing wrong with her, after all, as Abby Cadabby says, 

“She does things just a little differently, in a Julia sort of way.”


Just because she doesn’t respond in the way you expect, doesn’t mean you can’t be friends. 

Little kids are funny creatures, but they’re also perceptive and can be incredibly accepting of differences, once they understand them. 

Julia doesn’t look at Big Bird or Abby when they are talking to her, and she doesn’t always answer them right away. But the show is careful to point out that kids shouldn’t assume that she is rude or unfriendly or that she doesn’t like playing. In doing so, they debunk the stereotype that people with autism don’t need or want friends.

Julia is a joyful character who clearly enjoys her friends and their activities, and the Muppets model for kids how to reach out to people who don’t always respond in expected ways.

“Sometimes people with autism may do things that might seem confusing to you,” Alan tells Big Bird. “But you know what? Julia also does some things that you might want to try.”

The takeaway for kids (and adults): 

If you stop for a minute and listen, 

you might learn a new way of doing things, 

and make a friend.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/parenting/wp/2017/04/10/4-things-kids-and-adults-can-learn-from-sesame-streets-autistic-muppet/?utm_term=.ded16f4d17b0


Oct. 12, 2017 "TV's attempts at autistic characters get mixed reviews": Today I found this article by Sheryl Ubelacker in the Globe and Mail:



Characters with autism are increasingly finding prominence in film and television, most recently in the new TV network offering The Good Doctor and Atypical, which debuted in August on the streaming service Netflix.

Such series may provide viewers with a glimpse into the world of those with autism spectrum disorder, or ASD, but just how accurate and representative are these characters? 

And, more importantly, how has the autism community reacted to such portrayals?

“It’s been an interesting mix,” concedes Esther Rhee, national program director at Autism Speaks Canada.

“We’ve had feedback from individuals on the spectrum, from family members who say, 

‘I completely relate to some of these story lines,’ 

and we have others that feel that they’re not accurate reflections,” Rhee says.

 “So there’s no one response to it.”

While the shows’ creators may have imbued their characters with some features of autism, Rhee says their main purpose is to be entertaining, not educational. 

“And so we can’t have the expectations that people who don’t know a lot about autism are going to view each episode and then all of a sudden have an understanding of what’s happening in the autism community.”

Still, Rhee sees the inclusion of characters with ASD in film, television and on stage as generally positive

“These shows provide a starting point … and whether people agree or they disagree with the content, it’s still an opportunity to start having a discussion about autism.”

The Good Doctor ’s lead character Shaun Murphy (played by Freddie Highmore) is a newly minted pediatric surgeon with autism who’s hired by a big-city hospital over the objections of many of its senior medical staff.

Atypical focuses on Sam Gardner (played by Keir Gilchrist), an 18-year-old with ASD obsessed with all things Antarctica and subject to sensory overload from excessive noise and light, who’s intent on having a “normal” teenaged life.


No comments: